Garden 
Affiliate Disclosure
Some links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you. We do not buy, test, or physically handle the products we cover; our rankings come from aggregated owner reviews, ratings and expert consensus. Commissions never change our verdicts. How we rank · full disclosure.
The verdict. The Schlage Encode is the smart lock to buy when you want a real deadbolt that happens to be smart, rather than a smart device that happens to lock a door. Its 4.3-star average is a fair balance of a Grade 1 mechanical rating and hub-free Wi-Fi against genuine battery and connectivity gripes. Buy it for a front door you share with cleaners, guests or contractors. Skip it if you run Apple Home, or if Wi-Fi at your door is weak.
Best for a front door that needs built-in Wi-Fi, real hardware strength and up to 100 access codes
- Built-in Wi-Fi — no bridge, hub or extra dongle
- ANSI/BHMA Grade 1 residential security rating
- Up to 100 user codes, each schedulable
- Fingerprint-resistant capacitive touchscreen
- Alexa and Google Assistant, plus Key by Amazon in-home delivery
Why buy it: it is one of very few smart locks with a Grade 1 mechanical rating and native Wi-Fi in the same body — the hardware is a real deadbolt first and a gadget second.
What owners consistently praise
The hardware feels like a lock. This is the most repeated positive in the record. The Encode is an ANSI/BHMA Grade 1 deadbolt — the top residential grade — with a solid metal exterior escutcheon rather than a plastic shell. Owners upgrading from a budget smart lock describe the difference in the first ten seconds of handling it, and the throw of the bolt is often mentioned specifically.
No hub, no bridge, no extra box. Built-in Wi-Fi means you set it up on your network and you are finished. Owners who previously ran an August lock with a plug-in bridge, or a Z-Wave lock behind a hub, consistently rate this simplification as the reason they switched.
Codes at scale. Up to 100 user codes, each of which can be scheduled, is a real feature rather than a spec sheet number. Households with a dog walker on Tuesdays, a cleaner on Fridays and a contractor for six weeks use exactly this, and the notification when a specific code is used is what makes people trust it.
Install is genuinely a screwdriver job. It fits standard 2 1/8-inch bore doors, replaces an existing deadbolt with the same hardware, and owners routinely report finishing in twenty to thirty minutes. No wiring, no drilling for most doors.
What owners actually complain about
Battery life is the top complaint by a wide margin. A Wi-Fi radio in a battery-powered lock is a compromise, and this is where you pay for the convenience of no hub. Schlage says roughly six months on four AAs; a great many owners report three to five, and some report far less. The pattern in the reviews is clear: weak Wi-Fi at the door makes it dramatically worse, because the lock keeps retrying. Lithium AA cells and a mesh node near the entryway are the two fixes owners say actually work.
Wi-Fi dropouts and re-pairing. The second cluster of complaints is locks that fall off the network and need to be re-added, sometimes after a router change or firmware update. It is 2.4 GHz only, and merged-band mesh networks are a recurring culprit. When it happens the lock still works locally with codes and keys — but remote access and notifications, the reason for buying it, are gone until you fix it.
No Apple Home on this model. Buyers in iPhone households repeatedly discover after purchase that HomeKit needs the Encode Plus. That is a labeling problem more than a product fault, but it produces a steady stream of disappointed reviews.
The app. The Schlage Home app is functional and no more. Owners describe slow loading, occasional failures to report lock state, and an interface that lags behind the polish of the hardware. It is the single most common target of three-star reviews.
Motor noise and door fit. The motor is audible — not loud, but not discreet either, and owners with a bedroom near the front door notice. More important, the Encode is unforgiving of a poorly aligned strike. If the door has to be pulled to throw the bolt by hand, the motor will struggle, drain batteries and eventually report a jam. Aligning the strike plate before install prevents most of the failure reports.
Price. It sits well above budget smart locks, and buyers who wanted only keyless entry rather than remote control and audit history often conclude they paid for capability they never use.
Who it suits — and who should buy something else
Buy it if you want the strongest mechanical hardware in the mainstream smart lock market, you share access with several people on schedules, and your Wi-Fi reaches the front door properly.
Buy something else if you are on Apple Home — that means the Encode Plus, not this model. If you want fingerprint entry and a lower price, the eufy Smart Lock C220 is the direct alternative and is reviewed here. If you want to keep your existing keyed cylinder so nothing changes for the people who still carry keys, a retrofit lock that mounts over the interior thumbturn is the right shape — the full field is ranked in best smart locks. Renting out the property? See best smart locks for Airbnb. And before you commit, how long smart lock batteries last is worth five minutes. Whichever lock you land on, set a unique password and turn on two-factor authentication on the account the day you install it — the FTC lists both as baseline defenses for any connected device.
Specifications
| Spec | Schlage Encode |
|---|---|
| Connectivity | Built-in Wi-Fi, 2.4 GHz, no hub |
| Security rating | ANSI/BHMA Grade 1 residential |
| User codes | Up to 100, schedulable |
| Keypad | Capacitive touchscreen, fingerprint resistant |
| Power | 4 x AA, roughly 6 months rated |
| Backup entry | Physical keys, plus exterior 9V jump terminals |
| Door fit | Standard 2 1/8 in. bore, 1 3/8 to 1 3/4 in. thickness |
| Voice assistants | Alexa, Google Assistant |
| Apple Home | No — requires Encode Plus |
| Delivery integration | Key by Amazon in-home delivery |
How we reached this verdict
We never buy, install or physically handle the products on this site. This assessment is built from the aggregated owner-review record — star distribution, the specific content of the one- and two-star reviews, and what owners say after a full year of battery changes — plus manufacturer specifications, the ANSI/BHMA grading standard and expert consensus from established smart home publications. For smart locks we weight mechanical grade, real battery runtime against the rated figure, what still works when the network is down, and how the lock behaves on a door that is not perfectly aligned. The ANSI/BHMA grade covers the mechanical lock only; it's a separate axis from the cybersecurity baseline NIST recommends for connected consumer devices generally, worth checking on its own terms. Full method on how we rank.
More from this hub: Smart Home & Security · Best smart locks · eufy Smart Lock C220 review · Do smart locks work without Wi-Fi · How we rank
Check price on Amazon → (paid link)