Garden & Home Reviews is reader-supported. We earn affiliate commissions from qualifying purchases — how this works.

Impact Driver vs Drill/Driver: Which Should You Buy?

Home/Resources/Power Tools & Workshop/Impact Driver vs Drill/Driver
Golden-hour view of a person drilling into a timber board on a workbench, sawdust in the air

Affiliate Disclosure

Some links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you. We do not buy, test, or physically handle the products we cover; our rankings come from aggregated owner reviews, ratings and expert consensus. Commissions never change our verdicts. How we rank · full disclosure.

A drill/driver uses smooth, continuous rotary torque with an adjustable clutch and a chuck, making it the versatile tool for drilling holes and controlled screw driving; an impact driver adds rotational hammering bursts that deliver far more turning force, ideal for long screws, lag bolts and heavy driving. The drill is the generalist you reach for first; the impact driver is the high-torque driving specialist you add second. They overlap, but each clearly wins its own job, which is why many workshops keep both.

What's the difference?

The drill/driver applies steady rotation and has two defining features: a chuck (keyed or keyless) that clamps round-shank bits of many sizes, and an adjustable clutch that limits torque so it stops before overdriving a screw. That makes it precise. The impact driver spins like a drill until it hits resistance, then engages a hammer-and-anvil that adds rapid rotational blows, stacking extra torque in bursts. It has a 1/4-inch hex collet and no clutch. The result: the drill controls, the impact driver powers. A compact impact driver drives fasteners that would stall a similarly sized drill.

Over-the-shoulder view of a person drilling into a timber board on a workbench, sawdust in the air, in soft overcast light

Impact driver vs drill/driver at a glance

Drill / driverImpact driver
ForceSteady rotary torqueRotary + hammering bursts
Bit holderChuck (round + hex)1/4" hex quick-release collet
ClutchAdjustable, for controlNone
Best atDrilling holes, precise drivingLong screws, lag bolts, high torque
ControlHigh, easy to featherLower; more noise and vibration
BitsStandard drill and driver bitsImpact-rated hex-shank only
Typical price~$60–150~$100–200
Overhead view of a person drilling into a timber board on a workbench, sawdust in the air, in soft overcast light

Which is better for your work?

Reach for the drill when you're boring holes of any size, driving into delicate material, or need the clutch to set a consistent screw depth — pilot holes, hinge screws, larger bits and precision work all favor it. Reach for the impact driver when you're running a lot of screws, sinking long deck or framing screws and lag bolts, or backing out a fastener the drill stalls on. Remember the bit rule: the impact driver takes only 1/4-inch hex-shank bits, and its impacts can shatter standard bits, so use impact-rated accessories.

Can you use one instead of the other?

To a point. A drill can drive most screws just fine with its clutch — you only miss the impact driver on long or large fasteners where the drill stalls and your wrist takes the reaction torque. An impact driver can drill small holes with hex-shank bits, but it can't grip round-shank or large bits and gives no clutch control, so it can't fully replace the drill. That mutual gap is exactly why the two are sold as a combo.

Three-quarter view of a person drilling into a timber board on a workbench, sawdust in the air, in warm late-afternoon light

Which should you buy?

If budget allows only one, buy the drill/driver — it drills and drives with control and covers the broadest range of jobs. Add an impact driver when you're driving many or long fasteners and want the extra power and less fatigue. Because both share a battery platform on most brands, a two-tool combo kit is usually the best value.

Where to go next

Shopping now? Our picks for the best cordless drills and the best impact drivers rank current models on owner ratings and complaints. If you need real torque for bolts, see impact driver vs impact wrench, and for a full walkthrough, the difference between a drill and an impact driver. Everything sits under the power tools and workshop hub.

We never buy or physically test the tools we rank — our recommendations come from aggregated owner reviews and expert consensus, and the method is on how we rank.

Straight Answers

Frequently Asked

Can an impact driver replace a drill?

Not fully. An impact driver drives screws superbly and can bore holes with hex-shank bits, but it has no adjustable clutch and no keyed chuck, so it can't grip round-shank drill bits or set a controlled screw depth. For precise drilling — pilot holes, larger bits, delicate material — a drill/driver is better. Many people own both: the drill for holes and controlled work, the impact driver for driving lots of screws or long fasteners.

Why does an impact driver have more torque than a drill?

Because it adds a hammering mechanism. When the impact driver meets resistance, an internal hammer-and-anvil delivers rapid rotational blows in the turning direction on top of the normal spin, and those bursts multiply the effective torque. That's why a compact impact driver can sink a long lag screw that would stall a similarly sized drill. The trade-off is less fine control plus more noise and vibration, so it's not for delicate or precision work.

Does an impact driver need special bits?

Yes. An impact driver accepts only 1/4-inch hex-shank bits in its quick-release collet, and the repeated impacts can shatter standard bits, so impact-rated driver bits and hex-shank drill bits are recommended. Regular round-shank drill bits won't fit the collet at all. Matching impact-rated accessories to the tool prevents broken bits and gives cleaner results. A drill's chuck, by contrast, grips both round and hex shanks of many sizes.

Is an impact driver good for drilling holes?

For small to medium holes with hex-shank bits, yes — it's quick and light. But it struggles with larger bits and offers no fine speed control, so for accurate pilot holes, big spade or hole-saw bits, and clean work in delicate stock, a drill's chuck and variable clutch do a better job. If you drill a lot, keep a drill for holes and use the impact driver mainly for driving fasteners.

Which should I buy first, a drill or an impact driver?

Buy a drill/driver first — it both drills holes and drives screws with clutch control, covering the widest range of everyday jobs. Add an impact driver second once you're driving a lot of screws or long fasteners and want the extra power and less arm fatigue. Many brands sell the two as a combo kit on a shared battery platform, which is usually the best value and the setup most workshops end up with.